
I have a growing suspicion that one of the greatest crises of our time is a crisis of imagination.
Not because we lack creativity. We have become remarkably adept at imagining new technologies, new markets, new weapons, and new ways of organizing our lives. We can imagine machines that think, cities on Mars, and economies that grow indefinitely.
Yet we seem increasingly unable to imagine a world in which everyone has enough. A world in which differences need not become divisions, power need not become domination, and our flourishing need not come at the expense of someone else’s.
We can imagine almost anything, it seems, except another way of being human together. And perhaps even more troubling, we have become accustomed to calling this failure of imagination realism.
We are told that inequality is inevitable, violence is sometimes necessary, competition is simply human nature, and ecological destruction is the unfortunate price of progress. We are taught to regard scarcity as natural, exclusion as unavoidable, and the suffering of strangers as regrettable but ultimately beyond our responsibility.
These are not simply descriptions of the world. They are stories about what kind of world is possible. And stories have a way of becoming the worlds we inhabit.
The Stories That Hold Us Captive
Every society lives within an imagination of what is real, what matters, what is possible, and what must be accepted. These imaginations are rarely announced as such. They become embedded in our institutions, our economies, our political arrangements, our religious communities, and even our ordinary habits of speech.
We learn them long before we recognize them.
Consider how readily we describe human relationships through the language of markets. We speak of investing in friendships, maximizing our potential, competing for attention, building our personal brands, and measuring our worth through productivity.
Or consider how easily we imagine security as something achieved through separation: stronger borders, higher walls, greater surveillance, more weapons, and increasing distance from those we have learned to fear.
Even our spiritual lives can become captive to these imaginations. Faith becomes a private possession, salvation an individual achievement, and God a divine guarantor of the arrangements that benefit us.
The problem is not merely that some of these arrangements are unjust. It is that they train us to imagine injustice as inevitable.
The theologian Walter Brueggemann argued that the prophetic task involves nurturing an alternative consciousness capable of challenging the dominant imagination of a society. The prophets did not simply condemn what was wrong. They helped people perceive a reality beyond what the prevailing order declared possible.[1]
They exposed the false inevitability of empire. They announced that the world as it is need not have the final word. And they invited people to live as though another future were already approaching.
When Christianity Loses Its Imagination
I find this particularly troubling when I consider the history of Christianity. The Jesus Way emerged within the shadow of empire. Jesus announced good news to the poor, welcomed those pushed to the margins, challenged religious and political hierarchies, and gathered people into a radically different imagination of life together.
Jesus spoke of God’s Kin-dom.[2] A world in which the last could be first, enemies could become neighbors, strangers could become kin, and the hungry could be filled.
Yet across the centuries, Christianity has repeatedly exchanged this disruptive imagination for the apparent security of imperial power. We have blessed conquest, sanctified racial hierarchies, defended economic exploitation, and confused the expansion of Christian influence with the flourishing of God’s creation.
Willie James Jennings has helped me see how deeply Christian imagination was distorted through colonialism, racial formation, and the severing of people from land, place, and one another.[3] These were not simply failures to live up to Christian ideals. They were transformations in how Christians learned to perceive God, themselves, and their neighbors.
A distorted imagination can make domination appear faithful. It can make exclusion appear holy. It can even make cruelty appear necessary for the preservation of what we call good. This is one reason I have become increasingly interested in imagination as a theological category. Because the problem is not simply that we need better answers to our questions.
Sometimes we need to question the imagination that makes certain answers seem obvious.
Another World Is Already Becoming
But here is what gives me hope. The dominant imagination has never been the only imagination.
Even within systems of violence and domination, people have cultivated alternative ways of living. Enslaved people imagined freedom before emancipation became politically conceivable. Communities facing segregation organized forms of solidarity that anticipated the beloved community Martin Luther King Jr. proclaimed. Indigenous peoples have sustained relationships with land, ancestors, and future generations despite centuries of colonial efforts to sever those bonds. And in neighborhoods everywhere, people continue to practice forms of mutual care that refuse the assumption that we are merely isolated individuals competing for limited resources.
I see glimpses of this in my own neighborhood. When a neighbor is threatened, someone shows up. When a family faces hardship, others quietly bring food, offer rides, share resources, or simply refuse to let them face their circumstances alone. These gestures may seem small when measured against the machinery of political power or the scale of global suffering.
But I have begun to wonder whether we misunderstand their significance. Perhaps they are not simply acts of kindness within an otherwise unchangeable world. Perhaps they are signs of another world already becoming. Not because they resolve every injustice, but because they reveal possibilities that the dominant imagination cannot adequately explain. They suggest that human beings are capable of organizing life around something other than fear, accumulation, and control. They make another future imaginable. And sometimes, they make that future briefly tangible.
Toward a Shalomic Imagination
For years, I have been searching for language that might help me name this alternative way of perceiving and participating in the world. The phrase I have come to use is shalomic imagination. It brings together two ideas that have become increasingly important to my theological life.
The first is shalom.
Often translated as peace, the Hebrew word gestures toward something much richer than the absence of conflict. It evokes wholeness, well-being, right relationship, justice, and the flourishing of life together.[4]
Shalom is not simply something that happens inside an individual. It is relational. It concerns the well-being of people, communities, societies, and the more-than-human world. And it is profoundly reciprocal. My flourishing cannot finally be separated from yours. Nor can ours be separated from the health of the soil, the waters, the creatures, and the ecological communities that sustain us.
The second word is imagination.
By imagination,[5] I do not mean wishful thinking, escapism, or the ability to invent pleasing fantasies. I mean our capacity to perceive reality in ways that disclose possibilities not yet fully visible. Imagination shapes what we notice, what we value, what we believe is possible, and how we respond to the world.
It is not merely something we do with our minds. It is something we inhabit with our bodies, relationships, practices, and institutions. To cultivate a shalomic imagination, then, is to learn to perceive and participate in the world through the horizon of shalom.
It is to ask what becomes possible when the flourishing of creation, rather than the preservation of power, becomes our organizing vision. It is to recognize that our lives are bound together in ways that dominant cultural stories often conceal. And it is to become attentive to the places where another way of being human together is already emerging.
The Future Is Not Yet Settled
I am not suggesting that imagination alone will transform the world. Imagining justice is not the same as practicing it. Envisioning peace does not eliminate violence. And beautiful language about flourishing can become another form of evasion if it does not confront the structures that diminish life.
Imagination must take flesh.
Imagination must become embodied in practices, relationships, institutions, and forms of collective action. But before we can participate in another future, we must begin to recognize that another future is possible. The dominant arrangements of our world depend, in part, upon convincing us that there are no meaningful alternatives. The prophetic imagination refuses that conclusion.
So does the Jesus Way.
And so, I believe, does the divine longing we encounter in the biblical vision of shalom. Over the next several essays, I want to explore this possibility more deeply: What if shalom is not simply one of God’s goals, but an expression of God’s own loving life? What if imagination is not peripheral to theology but essential to how we know and participate in reality? What if flourishing is necessarily systemic, relational, and reciprocal? And what might all this mean for following Jesus in a world increasingly shaped by fear, fragmentation, and domination?
These are not questions I ask from a distance. They emerge from my life as a theologian, educator, neighbor, husband, father, and follower of the Jesus Way. They arise from my own failures of imagination as much as from the possibilities I have been privileged to witness.
I am learning that hope is not the conviction that everything will turn out well. Hope is the willingness to remain open to possibilities that the present order cannot yet see, and to participate faithfully in their becoming.
The world we have is real. Its suffering is real. Its injustices are real. But its arrangements are not eternal. And its future is not yet settled.
The world we have is not the world that must be.
Perhaps the first work of a shalomic imagination is simply to learn to see that another world is already becoming—and to ask what love might invite us to do next.
Peace, dwight
Endnotes
[1] Walter Brueggemann, The Prophetic Imagination, 2nd ed. (Minneapolis, MN: Fortress Press, 2001). Brueggemann describes the prophetic task as cultivating an alternative consciousness that challenges the dominant culture while energizing communities toward new possibilities.
[2] The expression “Kin-dom of God” is associated with Franciscan sister Georgene Wilson, O.S.F., and was subsequently developed and popularized by mujerista theologian Ada María Isasi-Díaz. Rejecting the patriarchal and hierarchical connotations of “kingdom,” Isasi-Díaz employed “kin-dom” to emphasize the familial, relational, and liberative character of God’s transforming presence. The term foregrounds mutual belonging, solidarity with the oppressed, and the emergence of a community in which all are recognized as kin. See Ada María Isasi-Díaz, En la lucha/In the Struggle: Elaborating a Mujerista Theology (Minneapolis, MN: Fortress Press, 1993), xi; and Isasi-Díaz, “Kin-dom of God: A Mujerista Proposal,” in In Our Own Words: Latino/a Renditions of Theology, ed. Benjamín Valentín (Maryknoll, NY: Orbis Books, 2010), 171–89.
[3] Willie James Jennings, The Christian Imagination: Theology and the Origins of Race (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2010). Jennings traces how colonialism, racial formation, and distorted relationships to land and belonging reshaped Christian theological imagination.
[4] For biblical explorations of shalom as well-being, wholeness, and communal flourishing, see Nicholas Wolterstorff, Until Justice and Peace Embrace (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans, 1983); and Perry B. Yoder, Shalom: The Bible’s Word for Salvation, Justice, and Peace (Newton, KS: Faith and Life Press, 1987).
[5] My use of imagination as a theological category emerges from several intersecting intellectual traditions. Søren Kierkegaard understands imagination as essential to the formation of the self and its capacity to envision possibility beyond the constraints of actuality. George MacDonald develops a theological account of imagination as a faculty through which divine truth may be apprehended and creatively embodied. Judith Wolfe retrieves and extends the significance of imagination for theological perception, interpretation, and engagement with reality. Walter Brueggemann’s prophetic imagination names the capacity to challenge dominant consciousness and evoke alternative social possibilities grounded in God’s liberating purposes. Willie James Jennings, particularly in his critique of the racialized and colonial formation of Christian imagination, demonstrates that imagination is never merely individual or abstract but is historically conditioned, socially embodied, and implicated in the formation or deformation of belonging. Esther Lightcap Meek’s covenant epistemology further deepens this account by understanding knowing as a relational, loving, and transformative participation in reality rather than detached observation or the mere acquisition of information. Together, these thinkers help illuminate imagination as more than a private mental faculty: it is a formative, relational, and socially consequential way of perceiving, inhabiting, and participating in the world. My proposal of shalomic imagination draws upon these traditions while extending them toward a systemic and reciprocal theological vision in which knowing, being, and becoming are inseparable dimensions of loving participation in God’s life and purposes. Shalomic imagination is thus not simply the capacity to envision alternative futures but a love-grounded way of perceiving and participating in the flourishing of persons, relationships, communities, and the whole creation—a way of inhabiting the present in light of God’s shalom, even as we participate in the emergence of futures not yet fully realized. See Søren Kierkegaard, The Sickness unto Death: A Christian Psychological Exposition for Upbuilding and Awakening, ed. and trans. Howard V. Hong and Edna H. Hong (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1980); George MacDonald, “The Imagination: Its Functions and Its Culture,” in A Dish of Orts: Chiefly Papers on the Imagination, and on Shakespeare (London, UK: Sampson Low, Marston, Searle, & Rivington, 1893); Judith Wolfe, Theological Imagination: The Legacy of Romanticism (London, UK: Bloomsbury T&T Clark, 2022); Walter Brueggemann, The Prophetic Imagination, 2nd ed. (Minneapolis, MN: Fortress Press, 2001); Willie James Jennings, The Christian Imagination: Theology and the Origins of Race (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2010); and Esther Lightcap Meek, Loving to Know: Introducing Covenant Epistemology (Eugene, OR: Cascade Books, 2011).
